| Men |
Women |
| 2024 - Sam Tandy (golf)/Nathaniel Wallace (football) |
2024 - Kelli McKinnon (volleyball) |
| 2023 - Cade Pugh (football) |
2023 - Sierra White (track and field) |
| 2022 - Cole Chancey (football) |
2022 - Emma Roberts (soccer) |
| 2021 - Ryder Yakel (baseball) |
2021 - Rylie Cox-Evans (tennis) |
| 2020 - Miles Humphreys (baseball) |
2020 - Emily Shell-Collins (track) |
| 2019 - Bryce Bray (football) |
2019 - Zoe Hardin (volleyball)/Peyton Mills (softball) |
| 2018 - Gavin De Los Santos (football) |
2018 - Madison Drennan (cross country/track) |
| 2017 - Park Parish (football) |
2017 - A'ndrea Haney (basketball) |
| 2016 - Jacob Gibson (basketball) |
2016 - Kelsey Taylor (cross country/track) |
| 2015 - Romo Westbrook (football) |
2015 - Ewa Zaborowska (cross country/track) |
| 2014 – Matt Calhoun (baseball) |
2014 – Mollie Arnold (volleyball)/Kristen Celsor (basketball/track) |
| 2013 – Zach Roddenberry (basketball) |
2013 – Tiffany Chambers (track) |
| 2012 – Chase Presley (baseball) |
2012 – Sierra Rollins (basketball) |
| 2011 – Stephen Blake (basketball) |
2011 – Janet Orgain (tennis) |
| 2010 – Marco Ruiz (tennis) |
2010 – Katy Grant (cc/track) |
| 2009 – Julius Kosgei (cc/track) |
2009 – Alicia Williams (tennis) |
| 2008 – Matt Hall (basketball, golf) |
2008 – Kendyl Washburn (soccer) |
| 2007 – Kyle Wess (football) |
2007 – Mary Brown (cc/track) |
| 2006 – Andrew Giron (tennis) |
2006 – Synda Veitenheimer (volleyball) |
| 2005 – Reed Fisher (cc/track) |
2005 – Amie Morrison (volleyball) |
| 2004 – Jacob Rotich (cc/track) |
2004 – Janet Kogo (cc/track) |
| 2003 – Aaron Farley (basketball, golf) |
2003 – Laura Tollett (tennis) |
| 2002 – Jacobo Martinez (tennis) |
2002 - Mindy Napier (basketball) |
| 2001 – Brad Whinery (football) |
2001 – Erika Pierson (volleyball) |
| 2000 – Marc Fager (football) |
2000 – Cheri Scharff Etheridge (CC/Track) |
| 1999 - Rob Stroud (football) |
1999 - Emily Prysock (basketball) |
| 1998 – John Richard Duke (basketball) |
1998 - Erika Harris (track) |
| 1997 - Clay Beason (football) |
1997 - Angie Dugger (basketball) |
| 1996 - Scott Alexander (football) |
1996 - Lori Hendricks (volleyball) |
| 1995 - Paul Mann (football) |
1995 - Penny Mayberry (track) |
| 1994 - Kyle Citty (football) |
1994 - Kymm Alexander (basketball) |
| 1993 – Steven Fitzhugh (football) |
1993 - Nancee Wilson (basketball) |
| 1992 - Matt Thompson (football) |
1992 - Kelsie Hutchinson (cc/track) |
| 1991 - Richie Roberts (tennis) |
1991 - Kelly Willingham (volleyball) |
| 1990 - John Spann (football) |
1990 - Melynda Davis Cordry (cc/track) |
| 1989 - Te Howard (cc/track) |
1989 - Cheryl Bednosky (cc/track) |
| 1988 - Marty Spears (baseball) |
1988 - Beverly Gardner (track) |
| 1987 - Shannon Hughes (basketball) |
1987 - Teresa Durham (cross country) |
| 1986 - Kenny Collins (basketball) |
1986 - Dawn Mason (volleyball, softball, track) |
| 1985 - Gordon Gerbholz (football) |
1985 - Karen Mason (softball, volleyball) |
| 1984 - Marty Ninemire (baseball) |
1985 - Karen Mason (softball, volleyball) |
| 1983 - Hubie Smith (basketball, golf) |
1984 - Marci Williams Crump (cross country) |
| 1982 - Carter Lambert (cross country, track) |
|
| 1981 - Richard Teixeira (cross country, track) |
|
| 1980 - Scott Carstens (tennis) |
|
| 1979 - Jeff Earnhart (football) |
|
| 1978 - Marshall Grate (cross country, track) |
|
| 1977 - Butch Gardner (basketball, track) |
|
| 1976 - Mark Trotter (swimming) |
|
| 1975 - Gary Beck (bowling) |
|
| 1974 - Tom Ed Gooden (football, track) |
|
| 1973 - Ed Eason (football) |
|
| 1972 - Jerry Cook (football) |
|
| 1971 - Dean Kilmer (football) |
|
| 1970 - Jerry Copeland (football) |
|
| 1969 - David Elliott (tennis) |
|
| 1968 - Harold Alexander (basketball) |
|
| 1967 - Cliff Clark (cross country, track) |
|
| 1966 - Jerry Baker (cross country, track) |
|
| 1965 - Ned Boaz (basketball) |
|
| 1964 - Vernon Rogers (basketball) |
|
| 1963 - Steve Smith (baseball, football, basketball, bowling) |
|
